Tuesday, November 18, 2008

New Media: Hulu & YouTube

Megan McDougall
Grady McGee

We chose to watch 30 Rock on hulu.com. Hulu only has the past five episodes of 30 Rock, but has many clips from past seasons. It also has a lot of clips that are supplemental to the show; it has interviews with cast and crew as well as "webisodes" featuring Kenneth "The Paige". The show's main page contains five subsections: clips, full episodes, details about the show such as a description and cast information, discussions, and user reviews. At the bottom of the page, there is a section of "Shows You Might Enjoy." For this program, the site recommends "Arrested Development", "Saturday Night Live", "The Mary Tyler Moore Show", "The Office", and "The Daily Show". Hulu offers quite a few options to share the program. It has a share feature where you can send a link to the episode to someone via e-mail or instant message. One of my favorite features is the embedding feature in which you can embed the video on nearly any website. The best quality of embedding on hulu is that you can choose a specific time frame from the clip to embed. There are also options to view the program in full-screen or high resolution. The site is very clean looking and almost free of ads. Their main source of advertising is commercials during breaks in the episodes. In a typical 30 minute show, there are about three or four advertisements.



We couldn't find complete episodes of any television program on YouTube. There were, however, many episodes of various shows broken into a few separate clips. We chose to watch episode one of the new US remake of Kath & Kim. It was in three parts, and the first segment didn't even start until the mid-opening credits. The program is presented on a pretty organized page with "related videos" to the right and "user comments" below. There is a share option in which you can send the video to someone or embed it on almost any other site. The comments section contains an area where users can post "video responses" to the clip. The "related videos" section contains 20 videos that are somehow related to the clip. The only advertisements are the ones that pop up on the lower side of the screen during the video. The three clips that form a nearly-complete episode were posted by a user named "michelle1111101". That is obviously not a network's username.




There are advantages and disadvantages to both sites. Hulu is much more organized than YouTube is. Hulu promotes mostly full episodes of television shows and full movies. Hulu is updated very frequently. For instance, a show that premiers on a Thursday night is usually on the site by Friday morning. A good quality of YouTube is that users can submit their own videos, while Hulu's videos are updated by networks and distributors. Hopefully YouTube won't become another Hulu. They both have distinct features that are unique to other sites.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I watched the episode of 30Rock, hosted by Hulu.com. The episode, just like everything else on Hulu, had a nice and neat presentation. I think that watching shows online is easy and convenient. I have always wanted to watch this show because I knew I'd like it but I am never home to catch it when it originally airs. Watching shows this way allows you to view them on your own time and with less commercials. Rather than watching a 21:30 minute show with 8:30 minutes of commercials, you are only forced to watch three 30 second commercials. I also liked that at the end of the show it didn't only throw out random recommendations based on the assumption that you liked that show; I was able to view lists of more 30 Rock episodes and clips of 30 Rock episodes.

marielle k said...

I watched the youtube clip of Kath and Kim. It was very choppy and the picture was not clear. Hulu is definitely the better site to use when you want good quality of the video you are watching. I also watched the episode of 30Rock hosted by hulu and it was much clearer and definitely not as choppy. Even though there were commercials, they were limited and really didn't distract from the episode. I would chose hulu over youtube if I wanted to watch a video with a higher picture quality.

Tara said...

Watching 30rock on hulu allowed me to watch it with my brother in his room while my parents watched csi on the tv in the living room. It was entertaining, and actually a show that I would not otherwise watch. But I was laughing at it and I enjoyed that I did not have to wait during long commercials, while at the same time when my brother left the room I was able to pause the episode and rewind it.

Javier G said...

I watched 30 Rock off of Hulu.com. It was clean and convenient to watch, as opposed to the episode of Kath and Kim off of YouTube. With Hulu you can watch the entire episode with minimal interruption, while with YouTube you must find the different parts of the episode and load them up. In all, the commercials with Hulu and the searching and loading of YouTube probably add up to the same amount of time.

AlyseLeaPhotography.com said...

Prior to this assignment, I had never used Hulu but I most definitely will now. I love getting involved in a good television series but because of my schedule it’s almost impossible to watch shows at the time they actually air. Hulu really helps with that problem. The quality of Hulu was great, the site was well organized, and had minimal advertisement during the shows and on the website. YouTube on the other had is quite different. Because anyone can submit anything to this site there is an abundance of clips and therefore it is much more chaotic. I agree with this group, when they said they hoped “YouTube won't become another Hulu. They both have distinct features that are unique to other sites.” If YouTube became more like Hulu it could probably make Hulu irrelevant, but as a viewer I think I like the sites being separate and very distinct from one another.

Blog Archive

ABOUT THE BLOG

This is the blog for the TR section of Media & Society, Fall 2008, at Texas A&M University - Corpus Christi. The blog will feature postings by students on a variety of media topics.